Sharda | • Reply
Bread looks very appetizing and I would love to make it. However, not sure how you want us to roll and fold the bread. Any pictures of videos?
Sharda
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Sharda,
This is another recipe with the same bread shape. It has a video and step by step photos on how to form it into a loaf.
Happy Baking!
mjmarcell | • Reply
Good taste and excellent structure. It is first class sandwich bread. It is also pretty easy and straightforward to make. It also is fairly quick for a leavened bread.
Terry O'NEILL | • Reply
After step 4 can I put the covered dough in the refrigerator overnight ? If so , what do I need to do in the morning to continue ?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Terry,
Yes you can do the first rise in the refrigerator, just make sure to cover tightly with plastic wrap so the dough doesn’t dry out. You may need to punch the dough down a few times so it doesn’t overflow.
Happy Baking!
KZ | • Reply
I read the recipe. Three tablespoons of butter goes into the bread batter. Then it appears only 1 tablespoon of melted butter is used on the top of two unbaked loaves . Coextensive? It doesn’t sound like very much. Could I increase the amount of butter poured on the top of the unbaked bread
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi KZ,
Yes you can certainly increase the amount of butter to brush on top of the loaves to your preference.
Happy Baking!
Donna | • Reply
I just have regular Instant Yeast. Will it work for this recipe? If yes, do I need to alter anything??
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
HI Donna,
Yes it will. No you do not need to alter anything. The substitution would be 1:1 and your rise times will be about the same.
Happy Baking!
kristin | • Reply
Can this recipe be successfully halved?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Kristin,
Yes you can certainly halve the recipe.
Happy Baking!
gwenne | • Reply
Could this recipe be halved? If not, can one loaf be frozen?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Gwenne,
Yes it can be halved to yield one loaf.
Happy Baking!
Brenda Thompson | • Reply
If I don’t have Platinum yeast can I use the regular kind?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Brenda,
Yes you can use active dry or quick rise to make this recipe. The substitution would be 1:1.
Happy Baking!
Frances | • Reply
I’d like to decrease the salt in this recipe by one teaspoon. Will it significantly matter as to the successful outcome?
Red Star Yeast |
Hi Frances,
No that amount is okay, you do need a minimum of 1/2 tsp in order to maintain the important yeast action-regulating functionality of salt in yeasted doughs though.
Happy Baking!
Ellen Lonsdale | • Reply
I do not have 8×4 pans. Can this be adjusted to fit 9×5 pans?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Ellen,
Yes use the same recipe amounts and your loaf size will be a little less dense. You will just need to watch the bake time as it will be likely be a less as well.
Happy Baking!
zzphrog | • Reply
I don’t have a mixer, can I do this by hand? I accidentally hit the five stars.
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hello,
Yes you can hand knead. I would use a wooden spoon or a Danish dough whisk to incorporate in all the ingredients. There are also some helpful tips in our Baking Resource Guide for kneading that you may want to reference.
Happy Baking!
Rosanne | • Reply
Hi there, yes I did make this bread yesterday and it is delicious, buttery and perfect for toasting. I think I forgot to put the salt in but it did not affect the baking process.. I will remember next time.. thanks for such a great and easy recipe.
Del;ght | • Reply
Can I used reg pillsbury flour?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hello,
Unfortunately, I would not recommend Pillsbury All Purpose Flour but you can use Pillsbury Bread Flour. The protein level of Pillsbury All Purpose Flour is only 10% while bread flour is 14%. Your rise will be greatly affected. If you want to use an All Purpose Flour the one I would recommend is King Arthur All Purpose flour which has a protein level of 12%.
Happy Baking!
Aim | • Reply
I use store brand all purpose flour all the time and this recipe has been on my regular rotation for 5 years or longer. Turns out perfect every time.
Jo-Ann King | • Reply
Isn’t the temp for the milk butter and water too high. I always thought it was 110 degrees to not kill the yeast
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Jo-Ann,
Since the flour mixture is at room temperature and then it is added to the warm liquids the temperature will decrease making it okay for the yeast. In any case though if the yeast was to be proofed by itself at these temperatures it would be okay. Yeast will deactivate at 140 degrees. (That is the temperature you want to avoid) The happy temperature for proofing though is 110-115 degrees.
Happy Baking!
Susan | • Reply
I have been baking all kinds of breads for 40 years. This is a delightful loaf that my whole family loved. It was perfect with my Leek and Potato Soup, made gorgeous toast the next morning and planning French toast tomorrow. It came together quickly and baked up beautifully. My dough was quite sticky, but I used plenty of flour for shaping and the texture was perfect thanks to Bread Flour.
Sharon | • Reply
In the ingredient it calls for 5-1/2 to 6 cups flour, below that in the directions it says mix 2-1/2 cups flour is that possible a typo?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Sharon,
Sorry for the confusion the flour amount is correct and is divided between 2 steps. In step 1: 2 1/2 cups is used. In step 3: 2- 2 1/2 cups is used, you will gradually add in your flour until a firm dough is formed. Go by look and feel to decide on the amount.
Happy Baking!
jingle.beep-0q | • Reply
I tweaked this Buttercrust recipe to last longer (maybe) and made it denser and softer. Overnighted 1 cup Montana AP and 1 cup water. Continued your other steps however I added a cup of apf as batter was bit runny. Added more minutes to my KA mixer to catch the window treatment test😊 and proceeded the rest.
It was so cool and surprising it overhang my 2 bread med. and pullman pans. But it was so good and created the effects I want. Thank you!
Jessica | • Reply
Delicious and so easy! I’ll be making this again. And again. And again!
Nick Kushak | • Reply
Can I use the butter top bread dough to make hamburger buns?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Nick – You can certainly give it a try. We also have Hamburger Bun recipes on our website that you may like to try: https://redstaryeast.com/recipes/category/yeast-buns-rolls/?_categories=hamburger-and-hot-dog-buns
Happy baking!
Kathy | • Reply
My first time making bread and it worked out perfectly! Would highly recommend this recipe
Rede Batcheller | • Reply
Hi! What kind of salt are you ‘prescribing’ that a Tablespoonful is required? I have in my kitchen Morton Canning and Pickling Salt, Celtic Sea Salt, Himalayan Pink Sea Salt (in a grinder), and Azure Market purified sea salt (which has some additional magnesium chloride to keep it pour- or shakeable. Some years ago I purchased a small, as in jewelry-stone size, scale and it should do for measuring grams and parts of grams. . . . can you translate the One Tablespoon of salt (i.e., sodium chloride) into grams, and then I think it won’t matter which “flavor” I choose? Many thanks. Oh, and by the bye — this is one of the best breads I’ve ever made or eaten.
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Rede – We’re so glad you enjoy this bread, it’s one of our favorites too! This recipe used just regular table salt. You can use other types of salt, just adjust to taste; however, we recommend using a minimum of 1 teaspoon.
Happy baking!
Linda K | • Reply
I’ve been a sourdough bread baker since 2020, and I nearly killed my starter a couple weeks ago. I found this recipe, had all the ingredients (I used powdered milk), and I have to say… WOW! I may be ‘discarding’ my starter more often! This bread stands up well to sloppy sandwiches and is equally tasty with a slather of butter.
Terri Eberhardt | • Reply
Can I use Buttermilk in place of the milk?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Yes you can.
Happy baking, Terri!
Barbara-Louisa | • Reply
Can you please put same without an electric mixer.thankyou
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Barbara – this recipe has both stand mixer and hand mixing/kneading directions (see step 3).
Happy baking!
Irene R Anderson | • Reply
A very successful bake. Quick and easy to make. My first rise rose so much in the 30 min. that I made 3 smaller loaves rather than 2. Smaller loaves but perfect for us.
Leslie | • Reply
My husband has declared this the best bread I have ever made!
Leigh | • Reply
Can the Platinum yeast be substituted with another yeast?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Leigh – Yes, instant (Quick Rise) or active dry yeast can be substituted 1-for-1. Just keep an eye on your dough as rise times may vary.
Happy baking!
Mark Smith | • Reply
Great recipe, my wife says I am now the bread maker in the house…..
Gena Costello | • Reply
I don’t have bread flour can I use all purpose? And I also only have active dry yeast will that work too?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Gena – Bread flour is recommended for this recipe. In a pinch, you can substitute all-purpose flour. Just keep in mind that absorption (amount of liquid needed), mixing, kneading and rise times may vary. Yes, substitute active dry yeast 1-for-1 – rise times may vary.
Happy baking!
Lisa A Lewis | • Reply
Made this last night! I’m an avid baker but am always on the lookout for a quick loaf when I’m short on time. This definitely fits the bill. Fast and delicious! I will keep this one in my hip pocket. Thank you……
Lisa | • Reply
1 tablespoon salt? That seems like a lot? Is that measurement correct?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Lisa – Yes, that is the correct amount. You can decrease to as little as 1 teaspoon if desired. Just keep an eye on your dough as this may change rise times.
Happy baking!
CHERYL P CABRAL | • Reply
Can you use 1% milk?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Yes.
Happy baking, Cheryl!
Debra | • Reply
Made this on a whim this week because of short time frame and instant yeast. AMAZING! So proud of myself. Would this recipe be a good “base” for cinnamon rolls? after 1st rise spread with cinnamon and sugar, roll, cut and 2nd rise? Like to try for Christmas. I will definitely make again
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Debra – so glad you enjoyed the bread! You can certainly use it for cinnamon rolls. It’s not a sweet dough, but it would work fine.
Happy baking!
Melissa J Lind | • Reply
Do I use 2 Platinum Instant Sourdough packages in the white bread recipe or one? Sounds silly but I gotta ask.
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Melissa,
Yes, use 2 packages of Platinum Instant Sourdough in this recipe.
Happy baking!
Carol
Melissa | • Reply
I have a 13″ pullman pan. Could I put all of the dough in this size pan?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Melissa,
Typically a 13x4x4″ Pullman pan can hold a dough made with 5-6 cups of flour. However, recipes with bread flour do rise more than whole wheat/whole grains, so this recipe may be too much dough. You can certainly give it a try, let us know how it turns out!
Happy baking!
Carol
Margaret Burke | • Reply
I’ve never been a big fan of white bread… until today. This recipe is a revelation in bread – very tasty on its own, makes the best French toast ever. And you can’t beat it for easy. Thanks, Red Star!
Liz | • Reply
Can you replace the milk with non-dairy milk like oat milk?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Liz,
Yes, that should work fine.
Happy baking!
Carol
Mary | • Reply
I made this today. It was fast and delicious. I halved the salt and it was still a little salty. Next time, I will cut it to 1 tsp. Was pleasantly surprised by how fast it was to make. Thanks!
Patricia | • Reply
Can I use Lily Brand flour?
Thank you!
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Yes, any brand bread flour will work.
Happy baking!
Carol
Thams | • Reply
I made this bread for the first time today and its was just YUMMY! I am new at bread making but this is by far the best loaf I have made so far! Thank you so much!
Dawn | • Reply
I’ve been making this bread for a couple of months now. I decreased the salt. Perfect for sandwiches, grilled cheese, and toast. Knowing what is in the bread and no preservatives is a bonus! Every time I bake a batch it looks just as posted.
olga | • Reply
How long would you knead with a dough hook. My hands aren’t the best for manual kneading.
Thanks
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Olga,
I would start at 4 minutes on low-medium speed. Base kneading more by how the dough looks and feel than by time. You want it to be smooth and elastic, it should pull away from the sides of the bowl towards the end of kneading.
Happy baking!
Carol
Marisa | • Reply
Hi Carol. Why does the list of ingredients ask for 5 1/2 – 6 cups of bread flour but the baking instructions says to use 2 1/2 cups of flour? Typo? Am I reading it wrong??
Can’t wait to try this recipe. Smells delicious already!!
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Marisa,
As you read through the rest of the directions, you will see that the remaining flour is added after the initial mixing.
Happy baking!
Carol
Carol Mondro | • Reply
I have 9″ x 5″ pans can I use these.
this bread sounds so good that I would love to try it.
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Carol,
Yes, you can use 9×5-inch pans. Just keep in mind that the loaves may not have as much height as those made in smaller pans.
Happy baking!
Carol
Carol Mondro | • Reply
Thank you for your help/ I would love a recipe that will fill my pans
Red Star Yeast |
You’re welcome. Many of our bread recipes call for a 9×5-inch pan. https://redstaryeast.com/?s=9×5
Linda macD | • Reply
Oh dear Lord‼️ phenomenal recipe, I made one of the loaves and the other half I place in a large muffin tin and frizzed the butter‼️ Can’t say enough, even the picky one broke his diet and ate a roll or two :0)
Rubydasch | • Reply
I love this recipe – it makes wonderful white bread. I recently got a grinder and have been grinding hard white wheat. I am wondering about trying this recipe with 1/2 freshly-milled whole wheat flour. I would probably add some vital wheat gluten. Should I do anything else different? Longer rising times or longer kneading? Thanks
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Rubydasch,
Since flour properties can vary greatly, you will need to experiment with your own milled flour to optimize this recipe. We always recommend going by how your dough feels instead of solely based on a set time (for kneading and rising). More info on kneading and rising can be found in our Baking Steps Guide: https://redstaryeast.com/yeast-baking-lessons/baking-steps-guide/.
Happy baking!
Carol
Kim Bradford | • Reply
Can this recipe be halved and made in my bread machine?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Kim,
Because this is not a ‘standard’ recipe (fast rise times), it is best made using traditional methods as indicated in the recipe. We do have a Bread Machine section with lots of recipes that I think you would enjoy baking >> https://redstaryeast.com/recipes/bread-machine-recipes/
I hope you will find this information helpful.
Happy baking!
Carol
Gabriel Grimes | • Reply
I recently halved this recipe and the bread was delicious tasting. I did find it to be a little dense so next time I’ll try to reduce the amount of salt.
Jessica | • Reply
Hi there – I am very excited to try this recipe out. I want to go home and do it right away! I have all the ingredients on hand, minus the yeast you recommended. I have active dry yeast. Would this work?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Jessica,
Yes, you can use active dry yeast in this recipe. Just keep an eye on your dough, as the rise times may be longer.
Happy baking!
Carol
JFG | • Reply
Would this recipe work in a bread machine? I am disabled and mixing dough by hand is difficult for me to do. I would make the dough in the machine, then finish by shaping the dough by hand. (Even doing that much can exhaust me) I love the results I get from red star bread machine yeast.
Thank You
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hello and thank you for your question. You can use the bread machine to mix and knead the dough. Thanks for baking with us!
Happy baking!
Carol
JFG | • Reply
I made this in my bread machine and it came out delicious!
Susan Wojcik | • Reply
This recipe is the best white bread recipe I have ever baked. I will be making this bread weekly! It so moist, a perfect sandwich bread,dipping in gravy or for toast in the morning.
I will be passing this bread recipe to my daughter’s after I present each of them with a loaf for Christmas.
Merry Christmas!
Robin | • Reply
Can use any kind of flour to make bread this is my first attempt to try this
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Robin,
We recommend bread flour – it is a strong flour that works best for yeast-raised doughs. https://redstaryeast.com/yeast-baking-lessons/common-baking-ingredients/flour/
If you have more questions, don’t hesitate to connect with us: https://redstaryeast.com/contact/
Happy baking!
Carol
Paul Pluth | • Reply
I made this bread for the first time today, and I didn’t have bread flour. I planned on adding some gluten flour, but forgot! It turned out nicely in spite of that. Next time, I’ll add some gluten or use bread flour.
25 Baked Bread Recipes: Taste Homemade | Chief Health | • Reply
[…] From: RedStarYeast […]
Maggie | • Reply
Wow !!! I was baking artisan bread today and wanted to make a white bread that would take less time, in effect making good use of the oven today. This bread is fantastic !! Lovely soft crumb, moist and the flavour, delicious. Thanks for a great recipe ?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Jean,
Please check your spam folder. I sent a reply on 5/15/18.
Kind regards,
Carol
Tom Bombadil's White Bread with Basil Butter, Honey, and Berries - Alison's Wonderland Recipes | • Reply
[…] I simply couldn’t resist recreating it for myself! I used a white bread recipe developed by Red Star Yeast, which produced a beautiful, soft, smooshy loaf. It paired wonderfully with basil butter, fresh […]
Roy | • Reply
I’ve made a varient of this for years. I add an egg or two during the first mix, and cut other liquid by 1/3 cup.
SometimesKate | • Reply
Will this recipe work using a banneton and a baking stone?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Kate,
I don’t see why it wouldn’t work. You may need to adjust the rise times and bake times. Let us know if you try it!
Happy baking!
Carol
Lynne | • Reply
Can I make this with instant yeast?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Lynne,
Yes, the recipe uses our Platinum yeast, which is an instant yeast with dough improvers. You can also use our Quick Rise (instant) Yeast.
Happy baking!
Carol
emilie | • Reply
I made this bread last night. It’s delicious – and so easy! Can I freeze the dough? Before or after the first rise? Also — can I do the first rise overnight in the refrigerator or will it overproof?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Emilie,
I’m glad to hear that you enjoyed the recipe! We don’t recommend freezing the dough – it will damage the gluten network in the dough as well as the yeast cells, which will result in poor rising. Here’s a link to some tips on freezing finished breads: https://redstaryeast.com/yeast-baking-lessons/postpone-baking/. If you do the first rise in the refrigerator, make sure to cover tightly with plastic wrap so the dough doesn’t dry out. You may need to punch the dough down a few times so it doesn’t overflow.
Happy baking!
Carol
Joan Wiscount | • Reply
Hi Cindy use Redstar Yeast (dry) freeze it and only thaw what I need for my needs I use the old fashioned method and sour dough starter never have a problem My whole family eat and take my bread home when they taste it even sceptics love Redstar is my choice.
Chris Casey | • Reply
I have been using Red Star yeast products for 60 years!! They have NEVER failed me and I believe Red Star is responsible for much of my reputation as a top baker. It is so delightful to see new young bakers who are just as excited and enthralled as I was all those years ago! Hat off to my RED STAR YEAST!
4 Easy to Make Bread Recipes – Keeping Myself Busy | • Reply
[…] Red Star Yeast’s 90-Minute Buttercrust Bread […]
Patricia | • Reply
Here in Holland we only have one kind of yeast ( the Dutch equivalent of the red star active dry yeast). I would like to make this bread but I assume that I need to adapt the recipe when using the normal active dry yeast… Does anyone know how to do this?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Patricia,
With Red Star Active Dry Yeast you can substitute it one-for-one with the Platinum yeast, just expect a longer rise time. I am not familiar with Dutch active dry yeast, but you can try this method — just keep an eye on the dough to make sure it’s risen enough before proceeding with the next step.
Happy baking!
Carol
Donella | • Reply
I make bread every week so consider myself a baker. This was very good and my hubby loved it. I mixed it in my Kitchen Aid and let it rise about an hour the first rise, punched down and rolled into ball and let it rise a second time on parchment. Then slipped it into my pre heated le crueset iron pan, on the parchment, covered and baked at 425 for 30 minutes. It was fantastic. Did not put butter on top. We like a crispy crust, so left it in the oven uncovered for another 5 minutes. Easy, peasy.
Paul Pluth | • Reply
Wow, I’m going to try this method!
Kathy Beech | • Reply
So, I’m not a baker…or at least I’ve never considered myself one, although I find myself baking more and more the older I get. I’ve attempted bread before, and I’ve always been disappointed! This time OMG, I MADE BREAD!!! It came out beautifully and it tastes delicious! Even my English hubby, who is very picky about bread loved it!! Thank you!!!
Richelle | • Reply
What fo you mean by “roll”? I am not understanding this.
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Richelle,
On lightly floured surface, roll or pat each half to a 14×7-inch rectangle.
>> Either use a rolling pin and ‘roll’ out the dough into a rectangle, or use your hands/fingers and pat/stretch the dough into a rectangle.
Starting with shorter side, roll up tightly, pressing dough into roll with each turn. Pinch edges and ends to seal.
>> Once formed into the rectangle, roll the dough with your hands into the shape of a log. Use pressure as you roll the dough into the log – keeping it tight.
I hope this helps!
Happy baking!
Carol
Katie Heston | • Reply
I just made this today. We’re getting some snow in later today, and it seemed perfect weather for chicken and rice soup and buttered bread. Oh my word, this is delicious bread. YUM.
Johanny | • Reply
I have been making this bread every week since I first tried it about 2 months ago. One loaf goes to my daughter and one I keep. Absolutely love it! I layer Swiss cheese on it before I roll it, and the flavor is fantastic.
Pat | • Reply
I am making this now with my students I have 8 mini loaf pans I am going to let is rise longer than 30 min the first time and it will work about 2 hours the second time because the kids won’t be here to bake.
We shall see how it comes out.
Pat
Terica | • Reply
I made this recipe this week. The flavor of the bread was good. I could see this being a good sandwich bread because the crust is not too crunchy- but I happened to eat it with stew. The texture is pretty thick- but I am new to bread making… So perhaps it is the technique I am using. Is there any way to make bread lighter and fluffier?
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
Hi Terica,
I’m so happy to hear you liked the bread! The denser texture/crumb is due to the shorter rise times. If you’d like a lighter, fluffier dough, you can increase the first rise time. Let the dough rise until it tests ‘ripe’ >> https://redstaryeast.com/yeast-baking-lessons/baking-steps-guide/rising-ripe-test-first-rise/. Let us know if you try it!
Happy baking!
Carol
Sandie Heindel | • Reply
I love this recipe and make it at least twice a week. Last time after first rise I divided it into 10 (4oz) balls. Rolled each out to a 8 in square the put ham and sharp cheese in, jelly rolled and placed in pan to rise. We had 10 delicious ham and cheese rollup for dinner.
Red Star Yeast |
Sounds delicious, Sandie!
LaDonna | • Reply
I wonder how the recipe would work if it was cut in half and use the dough setting on my bread machine?? I love to do my dough with the bread maker, never baked a loaf yet in it! Haha
Red Star Yeast | • Reply
LaDonna – that should work fine. Let us know if you try it!
Happy baking!
Carol@RSY
Rebecca Roper | • Reply
This recipe makes seriously delicious bread! I’ve made it three times this week. To make it dairy-free, I just used water and coconut oil in place of milk and butter. I seldom leave a comment, but I am so in love with this bread I wanted to tell the world.